American Idol and Do you think America made the right choice

[tonyaz_16127]

I don't know about you guys but this being the end of December means that another season of American Idol is soon to be upon us...

My question is:

Do you think we made the right choices in who won before?

Personally I did not see the first or third season so all I know about Kelly and Fantasia is what I see on tv and here on the net... But Rubin Studdard was a good choice at that time.

Carrie Underwood was the best choice for her season.

Jordin Sparks was the second-best this last year (Melinda Doolittle should have won).

Taylor Hicks has never impressed me and I do think we pulled another big goof when Chris Daughtry was eliminated. In another 10 years Taylor Hicks may only be a memory.I would have enjoyed Katherine McPhee over him winning.

What's your opinion?

Tony

[AYHJA]

I've never really gotten into the show...If its on, I might watch it though...I caught the last few episodes of the last season and really couldn't understand the fascination w/the show...I love to watch Simon rip into folk, but I don't think he's done that much of that stuff lately...Paula reminds me of a drunk aunt at the Thanksgiving table every time I see her on the screen...