The real deal at Arizona State
Posted: Wed Aug 23, 2006 2:14 pm
Around the Bristol, Conn., offices today, and everyone's asked me the same question: "So, what's the real deal at Arizona State?"
Well, from what I've heard, the real deal is what's been written in most of the Arizona newspapers. Arizona State coach Dirk Koetter chose sophomore Rudy Carpenter over senior Sam Keller, just a day after choosing Keller over Carpenter.
Come again? It appears the most recent quarterback decision was primarily the result of a meeting in which some ASU players told Koetter that they wanted Carpenter to be their quarterback.
Where is Keller now? Where is he headed next? Nobody knows for sure. But it sure looks like it won't be Arizona State.
People close to Carpenter praise his knowledge of the game, work ethic and commitment. They've also questioned some things about Keller. But it seems unnecessary to kick the man now, especially considering how sudden and shocking Koetter's reversal must have been for him. Those who support Keller will undoubtedly question Koetter's decision.
A person close to Carpenter says he was seriously considering transferring. But would he really have followed through with it?
Why not wait and see whether Keller got injured -- like last season -- or not perform as well as Carpenter performed down the stretch in 2005? Those close to Carpenter say his competitiveness would not have allowed him to sit on the sideline for just one season.
And so, Arizona State suddenly goes from having the strongest quarterback tandem in the nation to a rising star in Carpenter who led the nation in passing efficiency last season. And who, suddenly, has the weight of an entire program and his coach's future, on his shoulders.
That said, I thought I'd give a ring to new Arizona State offensive coordinator Roy Wittke, who graciously took my call. I was warned that Wittke had no desire to break down the details of Koetter's decision to switch from Keller to Carpenter, but would gladly break down Carpenter.
Schad: What have the last few days been like for you?
Wittke: It's been an interesting time. It's been difficult, but we have to do what's best for our team.
Schad: This is your first year there. What was your first impression of Rudy Carpenter?
Wittke: Well, he's a classic gym rat. He always wants to talk football. He's always asking questions. He's like that kid that raises his hand four or five times and sticks around afterward to make sure he asks things right and it pays off for him. And he's very accurate, not only from a physical standpoint, but also from a decision making standpoint.
Schad: What was the first thing you noticed when breaking down the film?
Wittke: His efficiency. And I'm stating the obvious. He's just a guy that is very steady, very smooth and very consistent with everything that he does. I was a little bit surprised when I first saw the tape about how mobile he is. He doesn't get credit for that. On tape he doesn't appear to have an overpowering arm, but his arm strength and range when you see him live and you're on the practice field is more impressive than what it appears to be on film. He throws a very catchable ball.
Schad: How do Rudy's teammates feel about him?
Wittke: Rudy rallies people around him naturally. He is a guy that you'll find in the office or in the film room with two or three wide receivers. Or with a few of our tight ends during the summer going over some cut-ups. He's a guy that understands and knows our system very well and understands not only what he's supposed to do, but what the rest of the people around him are supposed to do. And in a very positive sense, he is always trying to improve the play of his teammates.
Schad: How do you think Rudy might handle now being "the guy"?
Wittke: I don't think it will change him. I think he'll continue to be the strong leader that he is. He's a guy that people take to and it's because he's action first. He's got a great work ethic. He's tremendously competitive. And he's a guy that exemplifies our team motto of "Answer the scratch." He's all about football and he's about our team and doing whatever he can do.
Schad: Who does he remind you of?
Wittke: His total immersion into football reminds me of a kid we had at Eastern Illinois who's at Dallas now in Tony Romo. Different physically, but in overall accuracy and understanding of the game and that gym-rat mentality. Tony was the same type of leader. Neither one of them were guys that necessarily would grab a kid by the facemask and shake them, but more of a leadership-by-example and helping people along.
Schad: What's something Coach Koetter does that you've thought is neat?
Wittke: You know, our practice and preparation here is really centered around the development of our quarterbacks. I was really impressed when I watch Rudy and Sam on tape, it seemed they threw the ball so well under pressure and there is a reason for it. When our guys throw our individual routes, coach has often done this and now I'll do it, we actually take a bag or a shield and put pressure on them, so they're forced to throw under duress.
Schad: Hold on. You literally charge at them?
Wittke: Yeah, it's fun. Sometimes straight on. Sometimes from the side. That's how they learn to deal with pressure.
Carpenter seemed to thrive under pressure at the Insight Bowl last season, passing for 467 yards and four touchdowns, with no interceptions. It will be fascinating to see how he deals with the pressure of being a starting quarterback, on a team that clearly has his back, with no reason to look over his shoulder.
Well, from what I've heard, the real deal is what's been written in most of the Arizona newspapers. Arizona State coach Dirk Koetter chose sophomore Rudy Carpenter over senior Sam Keller, just a day after choosing Keller over Carpenter.
Come again? It appears the most recent quarterback decision was primarily the result of a meeting in which some ASU players told Koetter that they wanted Carpenter to be their quarterback.
Where is Keller now? Where is he headed next? Nobody knows for sure. But it sure looks like it won't be Arizona State.
People close to Carpenter praise his knowledge of the game, work ethic and commitment. They've also questioned some things about Keller. But it seems unnecessary to kick the man now, especially considering how sudden and shocking Koetter's reversal must have been for him. Those who support Keller will undoubtedly question Koetter's decision.
A person close to Carpenter says he was seriously considering transferring. But would he really have followed through with it?
Why not wait and see whether Keller got injured -- like last season -- or not perform as well as Carpenter performed down the stretch in 2005? Those close to Carpenter say his competitiveness would not have allowed him to sit on the sideline for just one season.
And so, Arizona State suddenly goes from having the strongest quarterback tandem in the nation to a rising star in Carpenter who led the nation in passing efficiency last season. And who, suddenly, has the weight of an entire program and his coach's future, on his shoulders.
That said, I thought I'd give a ring to new Arizona State offensive coordinator Roy Wittke, who graciously took my call. I was warned that Wittke had no desire to break down the details of Koetter's decision to switch from Keller to Carpenter, but would gladly break down Carpenter.
Schad: What have the last few days been like for you?
Wittke: It's been an interesting time. It's been difficult, but we have to do what's best for our team.
Schad: This is your first year there. What was your first impression of Rudy Carpenter?
Wittke: Well, he's a classic gym rat. He always wants to talk football. He's always asking questions. He's like that kid that raises his hand four or five times and sticks around afterward to make sure he asks things right and it pays off for him. And he's very accurate, not only from a physical standpoint, but also from a decision making standpoint.
Schad: What was the first thing you noticed when breaking down the film?
Wittke: His efficiency. And I'm stating the obvious. He's just a guy that is very steady, very smooth and very consistent with everything that he does. I was a little bit surprised when I first saw the tape about how mobile he is. He doesn't get credit for that. On tape he doesn't appear to have an overpowering arm, but his arm strength and range when you see him live and you're on the practice field is more impressive than what it appears to be on film. He throws a very catchable ball.
Schad: How do Rudy's teammates feel about him?
Wittke: Rudy rallies people around him naturally. He is a guy that you'll find in the office or in the film room with two or three wide receivers. Or with a few of our tight ends during the summer going over some cut-ups. He's a guy that understands and knows our system very well and understands not only what he's supposed to do, but what the rest of the people around him are supposed to do. And in a very positive sense, he is always trying to improve the play of his teammates.
Schad: How do you think Rudy might handle now being "the guy"?
Wittke: I don't think it will change him. I think he'll continue to be the strong leader that he is. He's a guy that people take to and it's because he's action first. He's got a great work ethic. He's tremendously competitive. And he's a guy that exemplifies our team motto of "Answer the scratch." He's all about football and he's about our team and doing whatever he can do.
Schad: Who does he remind you of?
Wittke: His total immersion into football reminds me of a kid we had at Eastern Illinois who's at Dallas now in Tony Romo. Different physically, but in overall accuracy and understanding of the game and that gym-rat mentality. Tony was the same type of leader. Neither one of them were guys that necessarily would grab a kid by the facemask and shake them, but more of a leadership-by-example and helping people along.
Schad: What's something Coach Koetter does that you've thought is neat?
Wittke: You know, our practice and preparation here is really centered around the development of our quarterbacks. I was really impressed when I watch Rudy and Sam on tape, it seemed they threw the ball so well under pressure and there is a reason for it. When our guys throw our individual routes, coach has often done this and now I'll do it, we actually take a bag or a shield and put pressure on them, so they're forced to throw under duress.
Schad: Hold on. You literally charge at them?
Wittke: Yeah, it's fun. Sometimes straight on. Sometimes from the side. That's how they learn to deal with pressure.
Carpenter seemed to thrive under pressure at the Insight Bowl last season, passing for 467 yards and four touchdowns, with no interceptions. It will be fascinating to see how he deals with the pressure of being a starting quarterback, on a team that clearly has his back, with no reason to look over his shoulder.